You are here

Opinions

Email Updates - Click here to subscribe for automatic notices when this page is updated.

The District of Arizona offers a database of opinions for the years 2012 to current, listed by year and judge.

Judicial opinions from the District of Arizona, as well as other participating courts from throughout the nation, can also be accessed through the U.S. Government Publishing Office's United States Courts Opinions web page. To view judicial opinions on the GPO’s website, click here.

Date Description Judgesort descending
12/27/12 Namwest, LLC et al v. Namwest-Town Lakes, LLC et al (2:08-ap-00860-CGC) 12/27/12

Holding: Although the Court has the discretion to grant attorneys’ fees because the claims arose out of contract, the Court denies the Namwest Parties’ applications for attorneys’ fees. The Kohan Parties’ factually complex claims had merit. The $640,000 fees requested would create an extreme hardship that would discourage others who believe they have oral contracts from bringing tenable claims. Furthermore, the fees requested are unreasonable, and the Court cannot determine if they are directly tied to the claims.

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
11/05/12 Alzubidi v. Abulaban (2:11-ap-01795-CGC) 11/05/12

Holding: The Plaintiffs have failed to prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the Debtor has committed an act that would support denial of his discharge under sections 727(a)(2)-(4).

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
08/15/07 Covenant Christian Center International, Inc. V. Mortgages Ltd. Et Al (2:07-ap-00055-CGC) 08/15/07

Under Advisement Decision re: Motion to Dismiss

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
12/11/09 Whc, Llc (2:09-bk-17092-CGC) 12/11/09

Under Advisement Decision Re: Motion for Relief from Stay

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
06/26/12 Mountainside Fitness Centers Of Gilbert, L.L.C. ; Thomas John Hatten (2:10-bk-23734-CGC) 06/26/12

Holding: Therefore, the landlord, R.S. Lots’ § 502(b)(6) damages consist of base rent and additional rent for the greater of one year or 15% of the remaining term of the Lease, calculated from the petition date. Any prepetition rent and damages awarded by this Court or the superior court not already paid are owed in full. R.S. Lots may recover from either Mountainside as lessor or Hatten as guarantor, but may recover only once. 

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
03/26/12 Oliphant Et Al V. Alaska Commission On Post Secondary Education Et A (2:11-ap-00626-CGC) 03/26/12

Under Advisement Decision Re Dischargeability of Student Loans

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
01/17/08 Sanders V. Oregon Dept Of Revenue (2:07-ap-00259-CGC) 01/17/08

Under Advisement Decision re: Motion for Summary Judgment

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
09/26/11 The Biltmore Bank Of Arizona V. Lund Et Al (2:09-ap-01577-CGC) 09/26/11

Under Advisement Decision

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
06/30/05 Rfi Realty, Inc. (2:04-bk-10486-CGC) 06/30/05

Memorandum Decision re: Motion to Assume Development Agreement with City of Santa Clarita

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)
07/05/07 Hanover Insurance Company V. Tmp International, Inc. Et Al (2:06-ap-00804-CGC) 07/05/07

Under Advisement Decision re: Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Company's Motion for Summary Judgment

Judge Charles G. Case II (retired)

Pages